Is it important to know stuff?
Of course it is but how does knowing stuff help when looking through thousands of lines of computer code because a program crashes without any error messages? How can knowing stuff help you manage a financial crisis at your company? If I read Shakespeare, will that allow me to work effectively in a team to brainstorm ideas to improve productivity of my company's manufacturing line? By the way, two of the members live in China and one lives in Europe and we collaborate using the latest Web 2.0 technologies. If I can factor a polynomial using the complete the square technique or be able to simplify a trigonometric expression using the identities, will I be able to sift through tons of information on the internet to make an informed decision on who I should vote for in the next presidential election?
Now, I have nothing against the old Bard or trigonometry but it seems that in education we believe that if all children are given the same content, somehow that creates equal opportunity. For the sake of the argument, let’s assume that all children are well fed and never abused. Let's take those children and put them in the same classroom in the same school with the same curriculum and give them the same tests and then graduate with the same piece of paper. Consistency must be the vehicle of opportunity...or is it? What about the child that sees the world with color and shape but has no art class? What about the child that can solve any logic puzzle but can't find the speed of train A traveling at 50mph? And more importantly, what about the child that just isn't interested in poetry but loves to read and write science fiction?
Consistency seems to be our society's rationalization for being too apathetic or preoccupied to think about the education problem. The pitfall is that it actually is important to know stuff…but it's pointless to teach STUFF without the context. To give the context you must start with the thinking. And to inspire critical thought, you must engage. Out of all those, content is the only measurable criteria. Unfortunately, educators are trained in such a way that they must be a master of their content and they must inspire their students to be as enthusiastic about their content as they are. I don't know about you but there are some things that just don't interest me (poetry, classical literature, advanced mathematics). There is nothing a teacher can do to inspire me to be a poet or read Charles Dickens. If we are to be sincerely empathetic we need to understand that young people have similar feelings toward content. However, whenever I say things like, "Do they really need algebra 2 right now?" it's heresy among mathematics teachers, and yet I have never come across a problem using matrices or determinants.
My point is this...if we want to build the School of the Future, we need to ask ourselves fundamental questions about what education is as an abstract, philosophical idea and what it means to manifest that idea in a classroom. There must be a veil of ignorance when answering the question, how should we educate young people? We must forget what and how we learned and also what and how we learned how to teach.
Knowledge is the cornerstone to an intelligent, well-rounded citizen, but it is only a cornerstone to a structure that is large and never complete. To use content to drive education is like watering a plant without soil. It might grow for a while but it will never reach its potential unless it is potted first. Content is almost incidental to the real vehicles of education. Without an initial focus on leadership, ethics and critical thinking, education is nothing more than a really expensive game of trivial pursuit.
Sunday, April 27, 2008
Content vs Stuff that actually matters
Friday, February 1, 2008
Classroom Observation
Here is what i see:
M is playing games. He always plays games no matter how much he is told not to.
K is sleeping. He is a nonpresence in the classroom.
V's laptop is at the help desk and is currently not doing anything.
K, T and J are half on task, completing their assignment and asking questions.
---After a walk through...
D is an advanced learner that I cannot reach no matter what I do; he is currently asleep.
---I need to start teach how I want to teach and stop messing around.
T is very bright but constantly gets frustrated when she doesn't understand math.
F and D have attendance issues and are so far behind that supporting them becomes a huge challenge.
There is a group that sits together and constantly misbehaves in very subtle ways. Even when split up their communication over IM or email detracts from their progress.
M surprised me by completing an online quiz with a 90% while playing a game the whole time.
K finally awoke with a grumpy look on his face at the end of class.
This section struggles the most with behavior and the content. They struggle with managing basic behaviors such as keeping their laptops closed during a modeling lesson. They also exhibit extreme apathy when it comes to actively engaging in the material. They are the section with the most "Not on the Radars" and "Novices".
I guess I was inspired to blog about this because I am tired of being unsuccessful. People always tell me that even when I don't feel successful I am always reaching some kids. I know this is true but I also know how much more successful I can be if I were more experienced, had more resources (state of the art technology doesn't count), were given feedback about my performance or just not have to worry about such extreme issues that accompany our struggle to build this school.
It seems as though, at this point, I need to focus all of my energy on my day to day planning and try to present the content in a meaningful and engaging way. As hard as that may be without a curriculum, it is absolutely necessary to be successful. I should try to outline a short term scope and sequence and then come up with activities as I go.
Monday, January 28, 2008
Observations and Reflections 2.0
To give readers of my blog updates of all my trials and tribulations while working at the School of the Future up until now would not only be impossible in any reasonable amount of time but extremely traumatic for me to relive all my frustrations. You might be wondering (if i have talked to you about my experiences) why I say things like "I wouldn't want to be doing anything else..." if I have these negative views. My only answer is this...no great accomplishment is ever easy but I know that someday, through all the mud and muck I will have been apart of accomplishing something that will be called great. With that said, I hope to re-introduce you to my experience of this roller coast ride called progressive education.
I recently attended EduCon 2.0 which is obviously an educational conference dedicated to the future of education. All weekend I attended workshops which presented ideas and strategies for innovative schools around the country. At first it was incredibly depressing because many of the topics being presented were things that my staff wanted to do at SOTF but have failed thus far. Just talking to my staff during the conference made me realize that we all have such intense passion but are slowly dying because of the constant obstacles we face every day. Maybe I can only speak for myself but I know that I was not doing or even trying to do what I got into teaching to do. But something happened to me at this conference...
During the last presentation on one of the days, this guy was speaking about how to teach with laptops in the classroom. It ended up being more about student engagement than anything else but he represented many of the same arguments that I believe. Whenever around educators in the past, these arguments usually led to a barrage of criticisms. So, just by listening, this guy put me in a state of mind that is very dangerous and yet incredibly powerful. I say this because when my passion takes over I don't have much of a filter on what I say or even do. To make a long story short, he took questions at the end and being the very last question, I lost complete control and expressed my frustration of the obstacles I face, desire to become better and passion for being innovative. He seemed a little surprised and didn't really know how to respond but what happened after he was done was one of the most exciting and exhilarating experiences of my life.
People started to approach me as if I showed something unique or extraordinary. I know I definitely showed my passion while I was speaking but to have other educators (and even the speaker) come up to you and tell you how much they appreciated what was said was so validating. I went on to meet other like minded educators dedicated to innovative teaching and learning. i walked away from the conference with contact information, new teaching ideas and resources, positive affirmation and hopefully a few friends.
Needless to say...I am back to where I need to be!
Tuesday, September 4, 2007
The Beginning...
There is so much I would like to share about this place, in this posting but would fill pages upon pages (the proverbial page obviously) with everything that is going through my head. For this reason, I will keep this posting brief and only concentrate on informing you about the path I have been on these past few months.
As I said before, after certain expeditions through jungles of red tape I was finally able to apply to the School of the Future (or as we call it in house, SOTF). The application was interesting. It took a number hours for me to complete because it essentially asked you to construct a project to be used within the curriculum. As I am currently building the actual curriculum, I now understand the purpose of that exercise; you cannot effectively teach at this school if you can only think in terms of your area of certification. That is, if you can only think of teaching math in the traditional way without being able to connect each topic to a real world problem and also not being able to connect it easily to other subject areas then SOTF is not a good fit.
I was eventually called in for an interview which I had heard was very different from typical interviews. There was three different parts of the interview. It started with a typical Q and A with a group of people (Educators, Learners and Parents) asking me an inordinate number of questions, some of which had 5 parts to them. This took about two hours to complete. I actually have no memory of what I said. I think I was on auto pilot after about an hour. The second part was a group interview where you work with other candidates on a certain task. You were given instructions to complete this task, some of which were missing and others were wrong. I cannot speak about the task I participated in because of a nondisclosure form I signed. What was bizarre about this was that I was the only candidate that day and was asked to complete the task as if I was working within a group. It was weird. The final part which I think was somewhat impromptu, was a face to face interview with the principle (chief learner). We spoke for another hour and a half about the interview, the school and any questions I had. I must have done well because I was offer a position on the spot.
I was hired in July and started work on August 1. After training, professional development, new learner orientation, chaos and curriculum development, it is now time for the second year of the School of the Future to begin. Are we ready? I'm not. All that I can say is, "Once more unto the breach, dear friends, once more."
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
Reprobating the Reprobaters
How Information Technology (i.e., computers, Internet) Can Be Integrated into the Instructional Process and Curriculum.The reason why I brought up my silent protesting is because when it comes to the topic of integrating technology in the curriculum, I have observed that most people haven't a clue. Not only are they clueless to how this can be done effectively, but they also aren't very familiar with the technology already out there. For most educators technology is PowerPoint and graphing calculators, both of which are either discouraged or over rated. I chose this topic to write on because I am confident that most of the people who read it will have almost no idea what I am talking about. And I even go as far as to criticize these very people for what I perceive to be inhibiting real change.
Most people would probably tell me to do whatever I have to do to get a job first and then you can be provocative but that just isn't my style. I like to challenge authority and fight institutionalized behavior. If these silent protest keep me from getting a job at a particular place then I didn't want to be there anyway. Here is my essay.
We have quickly entered into a new era of information technology, and the new generation of young people growing up in this era encounter and process information in a very different way than previous generations. For a few years this cultural schism has been known as the digital divide. To me, this represents a fundamental difference in the vehicle by which information is transferred to an individual. It was not long ago when children were essentially isolated from the outside world with most information being filtered by their parents. This new world in which we live, with information literally at one’s finger tips, completely opens this outside world to just about everyone. Instead of small amounts of filtered information, there is virtually an unlimited amount of completely unfiltered information. To some, this drastic change represents the complete degradation of society. But there are those of us who wish to embrace this information beast and who are trying to tame its chaotic nature in order to create new educational methods that will not only prepare our young people for this quickly changing world but also to begin to realize some of the ideals that education once believed in.
The new era of Web 2.0 offers assorted online applications to enhance the traditional style curriculum. Using these applications, students could practice and hone their skills in a new and possibly more creative way. One of the most important skills that educators can help foster in young people is that of information analysis. It is a shame that many institutions are going as far as banning resources such as Wikipedia for not being as "scholarly" or "reliable" as other sources. It is true that the internet has virtually unlimited amounts of information (both good and bad), but we as educators should be prepared to develop strategies and methods to make sure that students learn how to sift through the mounds of information. By only giving them "reliable" sources, we are missing a golden opportunity for genuine education. This new digital age may help students think critically while using different information resources within different mediums. Any tool designed to assist in this process should not be immediately reprobated.
Wikipedia is also one of many community based resources that represents a cooperative model of creative innovation that progressive curriculums strive to develop. MySpace, YouTube and blogs are all examples of opportunities educators have to create real and meaningful learning communities dedicated to creative and critical thinking. Superficially, these resources allow students to finally have a voice and an outlet to demonstrate their individuality and then even receive feedback from peers. At a deeper level, these new technologies provide a foundation for inventive people to collaborate and recreate (not reform) education from the bottom up.
Access to information is only half the battle when trying to understand the digital divide. After individuals access information, they need to have outlets to disseminate their perspective to others. We now have the technologies to do this quickly, efficiently, and over different mediums. Whether through video, audio, or text, Web 2.0 offers many free and easily accessible applications to disseminate our own personal perspectives. It is becoming easier for teachers to share their experiences of different teaching methods and reflect on why they may have worked or why they may not have worked. They can even upload and share resources used in their classrooms. However, many educators that are on the far side of the digital divide criticize these new modes of communication. They place blame on either the technology or the user for abusing what they believe to be the accepted social conventions of communication. This inhibits any possible innovation in education if an entire institution holds the same perspective. If we can find educators who ask how these new technologies can enhance education, rather than who assert how they hinder them, then we can start to see genuine evolution in education. Imagine digitally connected classrooms in which students collaborate with their peers from other schools whether across town or across an ocean, students and teachers alike sharing their perspectives and working online with others, giving and receiving feedback. Technology, at its core, is about opportunity – opportunity to change and to create tools to help us shape a better world. What could be more appropriate for education?
Saturday, March 24, 2007
The Wake Up Call
But this past we was a wake up call that deeply wounded my teaching self efficacy. What do you do when the students don't take you seriously? Obviously the answer is to establish your authority at the beginning and be consistent. The problem arises in both my situation and when you didn't effectively do that at the beginning. So now you are left with a classroom full of students that don't have any respect for your authority or your teaching.
As I said in a previously post, my coop was out all week and I was left to teach all 5 classes all week. I went into this week with a positive outlook due to probably my most successful lesson to date last Friday. That quickly changed on Tuesday when I found out that the students in every single class seemed to believe that because their "real" teacher wasn't there they had free reign over the classroom. The bad part about it was that they were right. I was completely unprepared for these challenges and was never able to get a footing. I couldn't keep their attention for more than a few minutes at a time. There were some students that were completely uncontrollable.
Let me be clear that nothing crazy happened. The classroom wasn't nearly as bad as some of the classrooms I have observed but a significant amount of time was dedicated to something other than instruction. When I tried different types of intervention the most effective yielded only temporary moments where I held the classes attention. I think what my coop said when I called him really makes sense. I was telling him about my difficulties and he said that my hammer was him. Without him around, I was left with very little to control the classes. I am not familiar with disciplinary procedures nor to I think I could use them effectively. I don't have the reputation or the "look" that some effective teachers seem to possess. The reputation that I have is that I am new or green which in many cases can be identified as a push over or easily manipulated. I have no plan for handling this until I can have my own classroom with my own rules that I can enforce from the beginning.
Here is an example:
Everyday day this student would stand in the doorway and look at or interact with people in the hallway. This would be before the bell would ring and would continue after the class has begun. Usually, I am inundated with questions or permission slips for the first few minutes. My coop says that I need to get more assertive at the beginning of the period and get people in their seats. So this student would stand in the doorway, doing whatever he was doing and would not respond to my demands that he take his seat. He never tried anything like that while my coop was here but this student seems to notice that he was able to act differently with me and he was absolutely right. Now, I could have threatened him with something like a loss of points of a write up. In both of those cases I have absolutely no clue. My coop has ultimate control over the grades and I am working within his point system and I think the discipline process is not only futile but ultimately counter productive with most students.
I don't know. Maybe I could have or should have tried a more authoritative approach but he truth is that I am uncomfortable with that system. It's complicated and rife with paperwork and process. I made many mistakes this week and set myself back in all of the classes. For the first time, I feel anxious about what I have identified as my calling. I have seen so much success and have learned and developed so much that this week was that much harder. I have an intense feeling of emptiness where there was once passion and enthusiasm. I believe it is temporary but it makes me wonder if teaching can be what I want it to be or if I am just living in a dreamworld.
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
The Substitutes
I met her after the "homeroom" period and she seemed like she was going to be fine. This is after she screwed up and forgot to escort the seniors to their assembly. It was just a miscommunication on someone's part that didn't result in anything bad accept the seniors were a little bit late.
The kicker was when during my first period algebra class when her cell phone went off. Now, things happen and we all forget to turn our cell phones off from time to time. So after a bit of chastisement from the students I thought it was going to be fine. Then.....THEN she answered the phone and had a not-so-quiet conversation for about...6 minutes. If THAT wasn't bad enough, she then proceeded to make another call. I don't think I have even experience something that rude in a movie theater. I had no idea how to respond and for about 5 seconds I was so flabbergasted that I think I just stood in front of the classroom with a blank stare on my face. The worst part of this experience which may be more sad than bad was that she was a classroom teacher for over thirty years in this same school. What in the world was she thinking?
Once again, this week, my coop was out for a surgery and there was another sub assigned to my classroom. She ended up being OK. Her intentions were good and she tried to help wherever she could. But my first impression of her was, to say the least, not very positive. During the first day she was here during the first period she did something completely inexplicable. I was doing a simple lesson on solving polynomial equations. On my first example when I got to the step where you have to set each factor to zero and then solve to find the root I was reviewing the Factor Theorem which says that in a factor x - r, r is a solution to the polynomial.
I then see her get up and approach me. She politely asks for the chalk and then goes on to teach for about 10 minutes while I was just standing there like an idiot. A student told me afterward that the look on my face was priceless. I don't know which look I was giving but I remember thinking that I wanted to tackle her. The funny thing is what she ended up teaching. She showed them that if you set the factors equal to zero and then solve for the variable you would end up with the root. Not only had we been doing this very same method for a few chapters but I was about to show the same thing while comparing the connection between this and the Factor Theorem.
I don't know. Maybe I looked like I needed help. At least she was trying to do something conducive to teaching as opposed to the crazy cell phone lady.
Tuesday, March 13, 2007
Those who can DO. Those who can't......
Boy do I hate that expression.
I agree that teaching is easy. Certification is a piece of cake. PRAXIS exams are a joke. Graduate school for education is comparable to taking 5 steps without tripping. When you actually get in the classroom, all you really need to do is read from the text book and copy examples on the board. All the work is done for you. While students complete their dittos, you can sit at your desk and browse the newspaper. Oh yeah, you also get summers off....SWEET! This must be why teachers are paid slightly more than professional lawn growth observers.
Teaching well, on the other hand, is just a bit more difficult. Here are some of the things a good teacher needs to do to be successful.
Create authentic teacher/student and student/student dialogue.
Develop creative and meaningful lessons.
Relate content to students' prior knowledge and experience.
Foster a positive learning community based on trust.
Constantly improve on classroom instructional techniques.
Maintain structured but light classroom atmosphere.
Discipline without creating conflict.
Teach to everyone without teaching to the middle.
Challenge the high achieving students.
Help the low achieving students.
Motivate the unmotivated.
Inspire the uninspired.
Intrigue the unintrigued.
The Less High Falutin
Assign appropriate classwork.
Assign appropriate homework.
Grade classwork.
Grade homework.
Create effective tests.
Grade tests.
Assign big creative projects.
Spend lots of time grading big creative projects.
Calm class down when they get loud.
Wake class up when they fall asleep.
Correct students without yelling or being negative.
Keeping from getting frustrated because of behavior.
Keeping from getting frustrated because of lack of ability level.
Keeping from getting frustrated because of lack of effort.
Take roll.
Complete weird roll sheet.
Looking out for misbehavior while I'm delivering the lesson.
Looking out for confusion while I'm delivering the lesson.
Think about the delivery of the lesson while I'm giving it.
Improving on my delivery of the lesson.
Improvise.
Answer questions.
Ask questions.
Respond positively.
Answer the door.
Answer the phone.
Make copies.
Check calculators after every period.
etcetera.
These are a few of the things good teachers do constantly to ensure their success and the success of the students. This is by for the most challenging thing I have ever done in my life. The fact that I am successful at it makes me believe that I have truly found my calling.
For those of you out there that think anyone with a half a brain can teach, I hope you are in the minority because the less emphasis our society places on education and the struggles teachers endure, the more we are facing a danger of this country being marginalized by the success of some developing nations.
Thursday, March 1, 2007
Evaluation #2
Calculators are used during entire lesson.
No behavior management problems. Students worked throughout the class period.
Make sure you wait until you have students attention before you give directions.
I'm not sure why this happened. It seems obvious that you shouldn't give directions to a group that isn't paying attention but I tried to anyway. I guess I was thinking that the directions would get their attention but that is definitely a bad way to get attention.
Started with quick pre-class work which was reviewed.
Randomly placed students in groups to complete worksheet. Students given quiz at the end and told groups their grade would be the average of the group.
I don't really like random groups but strategically placing students in groups is a lot of work which I am not yet prepared to do. I think it is important that I get better at the more fundamental aspects of teaching before I try to develop the more intermediate ideas.
Moved around classroom and worked with different group, answering questions.
Questions on worksheet are open ended and students need to use critical thinking skills to respond.
The worksheet was what I call guided discovery. The questions lead the students to develop the concepts of the lesson. In this case the concepts were properties of logarithmic functions. No group was able to independently derive the general form of any of the properties. I had to walk each group through the process of how to go from data to patterns to relationship to general formula. On one hand, it is disappointing that the students weren't able to see it but on the other, this is exactly what I mean when Italk about modeling critical thinking. I believe that if this activity is done enough then the students will eventually learn how to do this independently.
Good interaction between students in groups.
Most students were actively engaged and stayed on task during the entire class period.
Able to informally assess student understanding of concepts.
Would have been helpful to go over directions of quiz together - before they started. May have wanted to review worksheet with class and then given quiz.
The problem was that there just wasn't enough time for this activity to really sink in. I took the advice of some who said that my first activity was loaded with concepts and I cut down to the fundamental concepts. These students' critical reasoning ability is so under developed that they couldn't be adequately guided through these concepts during a full class period even when they were working at a phenomenal level.
(A) excellent B good C satisfactory D fair F poor
Wednesday, February 28, 2007
The Wonder of Structure
However, without giving up I tried to tweak the lesson. They had no motivation to complete the worksheet so for my second class, I gave an incentive. There were 4 questions, each worth 2 bonus points. If I had to help a a group more than once for a particular question they could only receive 1 point for that question. If they are at a standstill in the group, I wanted them to try to figure it out themselves. Not one group asked me more than 1 question on a problem. After 20 minutes, I checked each group's work. They were all completed and the lowest score was a 5 and I could actually finish the lesson.
After talking with my cooperating teacher, he thinks the structure and incentives made a difference but also the quality of the students. I don't know what I think but I wished I would have had the incentives in the first class.
Sunday, February 25, 2007
A Bit of Coaching
Hello Joe,
I teach my first lesson today and was wondering what you thought of it regarding the discussion we had.
Thanks
Tom
Tom
I think you have a lot here for one class. There's a lot of information and a lot of thought that goes with it. I think the students will get lost and frustrated. I think the folding activity is good.
Activity I had used were:
Having the class show exponential growth.
Shake one students hand..... Instruct them to shake Two more students hands and so on. Record the # of students who have shaken hands after each event.... That way the students see exponential growth in the class.......
You could do the same with passing along a secret to two students, they pass to two and so on......
If the class creates an activity then you should have an opportunity to dialogue with the students about what is happening. Let the students write what they think is happening and then guess what will happen after 5 events, 10 events etc....
It is when you can get the students voices going and dialogue about the work happening that the students will really understand the concept. If you get caught up in lecturing and giving out factoids you will lose them, they'll sleep or try to do what you ask like good students but they won't get it....
Authentic classes thrive on democratic dialogue. That is what you want to create. Always allow learning to be open to debate. Students need vigorous discussion in the class for education to be active and challenging. Teacher talk depresses students. Teacher monologue limits their speech and development.
Teacher talk will also depress you. Teachers thrive on responses to their labors, and silent classes weaken our moral. Without lively student participation, we risk declining into burnout.
Be bold and challenging. The students have been conditioned into cogs so getting them to participate is difficult.... don't give up though...
1) I sent an e mail to two students. Each student then sent an e mail to two other students
How many e mails were sent after this happened 2xs, 4xs, 10xs,,,, 20xs.....
Try to let the students discover the equations.... I'm sure that what you are working towards with the folded paper..
To make the activity even more authentic tell the students a secret... or pass along a hand shake. These get the class really involved in the process and students can see the process of exponential growth.
Joe
Joe
I would love to do these activities but they don't want it. Wherever I try to do something clever or engaging they look at me like I'm stupid. They wouldn't even fold the paper let alone actually shake hands. Students scoff at me when I give them critical thinking problems. They have confused looks when I relate it to real world situations. A typical educator would just tell me that I must be doing it wrong but I have yet to see it work in a typical inner city high school.
This could be because they aren't used to these types of activities and due to the fact that I am a stranger in the classroom. Also, I am still not convinced that there is enough time in the curriculum. Everything I did today was outlined in the guidelines book. I would love to be able to expand it and go into much greater depth but it seems to be completely unrealistic.
Thanks for all your comments. With your permission I would like to post your email in my online student teaching blog. And I will keep trying different things.
Tom
Tom
These kids are only responding to you in the only language they know. We have conditioned them to do what they are doing. You are now seeing what American educational systems are doing. As a student teacher you are experiencing the normative behavior of the class, teacher talk, student listen. The kids want you to talk while they sit and do little or nothing.
Yes our institutions discourage experimenting and may even punish teachers who rock the boat. Teacher talk can be the path of least resistance. This is not unique to the urban school. It happens everywhere. Most teachers talk and students listen. Dialogue is discouraged.
You are receiving on the job training, burdened with class size, poor recourses, restrictions of required test, texts, and syllabi. You lack any power at all. Only the students have less power than you. It's all run from the top down.
Creating authentic is dangerous, but it is also the greatest thing that has happened to my teaching. It has rejuvenated me and my calling. Today I believe from the bottom of my soul that the only true education happens when authentic dialogue happens in the classroom.
So where to go from here. I would suggest that you tell the students how you feel about the activity that you did. Let them know you are disappointed with the outcomes and that request that they tell you honestly what they felt. You might want them to write it first and share it with one another to get it going. A lot of times this gets them started talking. You must be prepared for honest answers though that may hurt your ego. If you do allow them to speak honestly, without insulting or embarrassing them. They will rise. Your class will rise.
If you can create dialogue in your class you will be able to teach them anything.... but the dialogue must come first.
Joe
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
Evaluation #1
Lesson plan extremely well written. Good objectives, shows knowledge of standards. Informal assessment being used.
Using calculators appropriate for lesson and allowed students to see concept.
You used a lot of critical thinking concepts in your lesson but didn't allow them to be fully developed.
This criticism is hard to talk about. How can I allow them to develop the concepts more? It's is to say it but helping me do it is another story. I guess I could allow more time for my intro activity of folding paper. The concept was that exponential functions grow or decay at increasing or decreasing rates. When folding a piece of paper in half over and over again, the thickness increases slowly at first but since the thickness doubles every time, at some point it explodes. If I put them in groups and let them collect data themselves they may have been able to see the increasing thickness even after you could no longer fold a piece of paper.
Students well behaved, no management problem. It appeared that only a portion of students were actually involved in a lesson.
I agree that I can affect a larger group of students if I create a classroom of active learning but there is no way that I can get to everyone. Education needs to change drastically if we are going to reach all students.
Idea of handing out personal "notes" is a good idea.
This is a response to my idea of making up notes (my way) and then having blanks that they fill in as I lecture. This idea is from Mr. Shilingo, my high school physics teacher.
Make sure you talk to the entire class, you were taking responses mostly from right side of room.
When I am teaching, I am constantly trying to think about where my lesson is going, how am I going to ask some question or how much time do I have. Eventually, I need to sort of go on auto pilot where my focus is on the entire class rather than my lesson. Also, I am going to write names on small slips of paper and ask questions to specific students picked randomly.
You need to give students time to catch up with you. You presented some of the material too quickly. Give them time to respond.
I have been working on this by pausing after I do an example or by asking if I need to slow down.
Try moving around the room to check on their work. See if they are able to follow along.
I love moving around the room while I teach but the classroom I am in is definitely not setup to allow me to do this easily. The room is packed with desks with two teacher desks in the front of the room, severely limiting my mobility. My room would be setup much different. I would like to have my desk in the back or off to the side (so it's not the focus) and I would like to have the desks pointing inward either like a v of a horseshoe. This would give me the mobility I need while creating a different environment where the teacher can move in and out of the spotlight.
You did ask for questions but no one raised any you moved on. It might be good to ask some and call on random students to see if they comprehend.
I will probably use slips of paper with the students' names written on them and randomly pick on students to answer questions. When I try this now, I don't really get any responses.
Classwork question was a great critical thinking question. May have been good to have pairs work together to solve.
Pair sharing is almost impossible to do in these classes. They have no clue how to move into pairs or why it is even necessary. With rigid structure it takes too much time and without the structure they either don't move or they end up discussing with many more people.
A excellent (B)good C satisfactory D fair F poor
Friday, February 16, 2007
Today...
I have a tendency to become over bearing and even condescending when talking about a passionate subject but I have always noticed that when I am speaking to an audience from a certain level of authority, I can adopt a comfortable demeanor. It is how I am able to successfully teach people about things I am knowledgeable about. I think the problem arises when I speak to peers and I am under the assumption that they should be as knowledgeable about a particular subject or that their arguments should be as good as mine or better. If this is not the case, sometimes I can be pompous.
However, I have the ability to take on a nonthreatening persona when I stand in front of a class, I think, because I am under a different assumption that these people have a desire to enrich themselves even if they generally don't show it. I know this isn't wrong or even too ideal; Students, under certain circumstances, can accomplish some pretty extraordinary feats. It's this assumption that I am able to have undaunted patience to try different things to spark their interest. If I am successful at this then my job is easy and incredibly rewarding.
The problem, that I noticed today, is that it might not be an unrealistic assumption that causes me to be condescending. I think it has something to do with openness or effort. Openness is essential for people to embark on mutual discovery of different perspectives. Passion can be involved but only when there is a sense of reciprocity where I want to hear what you have to say, not so I can disagree but so I can compare your perspective to mine and others in order to investigate logical implications. This is in the hope of discovering new ways of thinking about a subject that might make more sense than it did before. I like to think of it in terms of the literal meaning of the word philosophy, 'the love or pursuit of truth.' All too often people close up because they feel their ideas were attacked just because of some disagreement or strong counter arguments.
Effort, on the other hand, is important for me to recognize in a person because it represents their internal motivation or will to improve themselves and the world around them. If I encounter a situation where I perceive that another person just doesn't seem to care, try to see other perspectives, gives up when faced with positive confrontation or gives up when faced with confusion, I first feel a sense of deep frustration because I see it as an attack on my passion for meaningful conversation and then judge them because I feel they are wrong to give up. Sometimes, my reaction to feeling hurt is to take a negative demeanor where I patronize them.
Today...I had the opportunity to create a lesson that I feel very strongly about. They lesson was on one problem but it was a problem that was about finding a well reasoned strategy and then justifying it. I introduced this new kind of math problem to them by saying that too often math is left in a vacuum where relevancy is rarely discussed or poorly discussed. Problems arise everyday and some have solutions and some seem to not have any solution or many solutions. I started the lesson with a simple question: "What is a problem?"
During my third lesson two female students, that often express their negativity during class, made a few comments that struck at the heart of my passion and enthusiasm. When they moved into a group activity one expressed that she "didn't know what the hell I was talking about" and that she didn't understand why I was talking about "social sciences." I tried to explain to her that I was trying to broaden the class to encompass many different ideas and to bring in other subjects. She did not hide her disapproval. While presenting a possible solution to the problem I asked a question which was more of a rhetorical question to highlight an important part of the problem. They both made comments about how confused they were and how much they thought what I was doing was stupid. I rolled my eyes. Being frustrated, I asked if they would have rather I started the new chapter and went to a lecture style class. Expecting that they would choose this type of lesson I was understandably surprised when they voiced their opinion to start the new chapter. Not able to continue with the solution I addressed the whole class positively about why I believed that what I was doing was important. I needed to take my frustration and vent it in a way where students were not attacked. It worked (at least for me) and I continued the lesson.
Why do I believe they were so unhappy with the lesson? I think they don't want to be challenged. They have gone their whole lives never being challenged in school. High school is merely a necessary step to get past in order to go to college or start working. They don't want to exert that type of effort. They want me to give them answers so they can regurgitate it on the test. Too bad they can't even do that very well. I want to get them in a room and shout, "What do you want from me?" They were not open to a different kind of lesson and they didn't want to expert much mental effort to figure out a real math problem. This got to me. But after reflecting I have come to this conclusion: We failed these students. I believe that if I show them something different, if I show them what math is really about, then they will eventually come around and start being engaged in their learning experience.
Monday, February 12, 2007
Observer Effect
The key word I used was benchmark. I would define a benchmark as a test to assess some predetermined level of quality or it may be used to compare the results of one test to others who have taken the same test. There are benchmark programs for computers where you run it and get an arbitrary score which is compared to other computer users who run the same benchmark. The significance of the test is seen through the comparison. You can see how different hardware configurations can result in higher or lower scores which may affect which pieces of hardware consumers want to purchase. A benchmark within education is a state test which is compared to previous tests by the same school to determine if that school achieved a level of predetermined progress. The idea is that each school needs to be constantly improving their test scores.
The problem with benchmarks is that people tend to construct unrealistic scenarios where benchmarks produce a higher score without providing an accurate measure of performance. Nvidia, a popular graphics processor manufacturer, came under fire a few years ago because it programmed specific instructions into the processor code which allowed certain Nvidia graphics cards to score higher on a popular benchmarking program. This is called benchmark inflation. Unfortunately, this now occurs in education. Nvidia inflated its scores to sell more graphics cards which make them more money; Schools try to inflate scores because they don’t want any federal regulation which, in many cases, results in them losing money. If tests scores of a school do not meet AYP (annual yearly progress) then that school goes under review by the federal government. This review process may result in any number of interventions.
Schools try to inflate scores by both aligning their curriculum according to the test (i.e. changing the year in which algebra II is taken – Alg I, Geometry, Alg II, PreCalc) and by specifically allocating lessons used to prepare students for the tests. Every Monday a class period is used to review problems that may appear on the PSSA. Every Tuesday a 15 minute practice PSSA quiz is given to the students. This is over 1/5 of the curriculum spent on reviewing for a benchmark. How is this not a disservice to the students? And how is this supposed to accurately measure students’ ability?
The goal of the federal government with NCLB is to assess how effective schools are and then hold educators accountable for any failures that may occur. Their mandates for state assessment exams are an attempt to observe the effectiveness of the public education system. This observation is fundamentally changing the system. High accountability is forcing schools to change strategies and build new curricula around these state assessments. We are no longer observing or assessing the original education system, hence, the Observer Effect. Could this be their goal? Maybe but how then are we to determine how effective the assessment exams are? Who determines the quality of the assessments? How are we to assess the assessments which assess the assessments…?
Wednesday, February 7, 2007
Prompt #3
What are effective teacher behaviors?
What does effective teaching mean to you?
Well from a student's point of view I think effective teaching would very unique to each student. Given that, effective teaching is meeting all student's needs. I'm not sure to what extent I agree with this statement but teaching is one of the more altruistic positions where teachers need to be dedicated to the students. My teaching aspirations define what I think effective teaching is. I want to be able to give students an understanding of mathematics that reaches much further than content. If a teacher is able to use content to teach and model ethics, leadership and engagement while being understanding and entertaining then students are given an experience rather than a boring place to go during the day.
Effective teaching behaviors are those in which teachers maintain a structured class while also creating an environment where students have the reasonable opportunity to be engaged. I say reasonable because a traditional classroom does not provide an atmosphere where students can be inspired. Some students are able to succeed but their motivation has nothing to do with the class. These students are naturally curious and engaged and need little instruction. Other students need to be shown that engagement in the classroom can occur. It is almost like they need to be taught curiosity. This is what I mean by provide a reasonable opportunity. You could also think about it as providing a reasonable choice. Students choose to be engaged in the classroom. If you were a student, would you enjoy your lessons or would they be boring?
This will be my greatest challenge, trying to provide these engaging lessons. These students haven't experienced this type of instruction. They don't understand what it means to think of mathematics outside of the textbook. To them, its a subject not an idea. To them, its necessary instead of interesting. To them, it can't be fun. With everything teachers need to do, how can we be expected to constantly develop creative lessons. These lessons require time to do research and effort to adapt personal style. In a typical day, where the curriculum is rigid and content focused and with only one prep period, how is this to be done?
Monday, February 5, 2007
First Full Day
On Monday, I developed a lesson and taught 4 algebra II classes. It was a review for the practice PSSA quiz on Tuesday. I tried to set it up in three parts. I used the first 15 minutes to model how to complete the problems. Then I gave them a practice quiz which they were to complete by themselves in 15 minutes. For the remainder of the period, I had them pair up and check their answers while completing on quiz with both names of the partners. There were many problems, the main being that a large number of students have absolutely no motivation to do quality work. Even though I model how to solve each problem on the board, they refuse to write very many steps down. Many asked questions when not understanding but an alarming number of them refuse to even ask for help.
Another issue is a procedural one. I said they could work in pairs but I knew that it wouldn’t work like I wanted it to. I say it was a procedural problem because the cooperating teacher did not establish it at the beginning. If I were to have assigned partners there would have been a problem. If I were to have said, “turn to your left…” there would have been a problem. They ended up working with many people and most people turned in their own quiz. I could have either concentrated on making sure people were working correctly or help with questions. I don’t know how to make this any better for upcoming lessons.
Wednesday, January 31, 2007
Prompt #2
I was asked to define critical thinking as a journal prompt for my seminar class. It was an interesting question because this is one of my 3 paragons of teaching and at first I was at a loss of words to define it. The first thing that came to me was that the answer to a question isn’t immediately known. This came from my ‘how to teach problem solving’ class. I think I said this because when you are given a problem to solve and the method for solving it is already known, then solving it merely becomes an exercise rather than an activity. There is no curiosity or discovery involved when completing exercises.
I then expanded on that statement by saying that, given this problem, one has to sift through related information in order to develop a well reasoned explanation that leads to a reasonable conclusion. If anyone knows my background then it is apparent what inspired this definition. This is basically a corner stone to philosophical thought. If you think about it a typical mathematical problem and a philosophical problem have the same basic components. The only difference is that the math problem has a definitive answer. The path to each conclusion is much the same. In both cases, one must justify the answer or conclusion with reasonable evidence. In a math problem the reasonable evidence is seen in the strategy used to solve it and the process of implementing the strategy. Both types of problems have flaws which are uncovered by close scrutiny. These flaws are essentially the use of faulty logic. Both mathematics and philosophy are governed by the strict rational framework of logic. One might argue logic’s intimate relationship with physical reality but I can save that entry for a later date.
Active Learning
To gain an understanding I think a discussion on passive learning may be helpful. Passive learning usually occurs in a traditional classroom where lecture is the predominate instructional strategy. The class is strongly teacher directed which means that the teacher is seen (by the students) as the sole proprietor of all learnable information. Passive learning describes how students learn in this setting. They listen to information given orally which they either copy in their notes or try to memorize. Now, I am not saying this is a bad strategy. Depending on the teacher, I really like lectures. There is definitely something that appeals to me when I listen to someone that is knowledgeable and impassioned. The reason why passive learning is not desired in the classroom is because it is usually ineffective for most students. An atmosphere of passive learning is usually one in which does not inspire engagement in the content. Only students that bring motivation or interest to the table are able to engage.
So is active learning the opposite? I don’t really know. I know how I define it but who knows what kind of highfalutin language theorists use. To me active learning can almost be taken very literally where students play an active role in what they are learning. Taken to an extreme it defines curricula where students pursue their own interests within an educational framework. It is about autonomy and self-determination. A more realistic or even pragmatic definition might describe an atmosphere where students are more involved in the lessons. Instead of lessons where lecture drives the instruction, activities are planned that use analogies and other relationships to illustrate abstract concepts. I feign from using the phrase “real-world” examples because in mathematics, real-world examples or applications are not realistic at all and most realistic applications are far beyond any level of high school mathematics. Discussions, Socratic questioning, cooperative learning, differentiated instruction are just a few strategies that could be used to create an active learning classroom. The teacher tells less and intrigues more; it is getting students to learn through questioning and curiosity. The teacher stops teaching and starts guiding students through their education while being a model of a good learner.
Premature Lesson
Today, I was asked to teach a calculus lesson for another teacher. For the past few days we have been having a discussion on how to best present “area under the curve.” Being my favorite topic in all of mathematics, I agreed to teach it. The teacher was unsure how to connect the sigma notation with the sum of the areas of the rectangles. In fact, I was having trouble developing a method of breaking the concepts down to a level that these students would be able to understand. Earlier in the day I had a mathematical epiphany while taking a leak. I was having a problem relating i into the sigma notation. The solution was simple. The i represents which rectangle of which you are attempting to find the area in the summation.
I observed the class before and I knew some of the students. Since this is an AP Calculus class, the students were all highly motivated and easily engaged. They also like to have a lot of fun which made my job extremely easy (the classroom management part anyway). I was surprised that I was actually a little nervous right before I started the lesson but as soon as I started speaking I remembered how teaching felt over the summer and I immediately became acclimated. The lesson went very well and it was fun interacting with students who knew how to both have fun in the classroom but doing it while participating in the lesson.
A few criticisms:
In general, I have noticed that students in this school do not know how to take notes. Their teachers never required it so they never developed the habits. This calculus class was filled with intelligent students that didn’t know how to take good notes. I knew this going in and tried to implement a strategy. One thing I noticed while I taught in the summer is that when my notes on the board are organized and accurate, that has a direct positive effect on the students’ performance. The first step in teaching how to taking notes is to model good note taking behaviors and force the students to write what you write. I attempted to do this. I put together organized notes on my clipboard and intended to given them an example of good notes. The quality of my notes quickly degraded. One reason is because I need more chalkboard practice. Notes on loose-leaf don’t translate the same on a chalkboard. The other reason is the organic style in which I try to teach. You can’t always plan on how to reach different learning styles. Sometimes you need to think on your feet to be able to break a concept down. The Fundamental Theorem of Calculus is a complicated, multitiered concept that is difficult to see the big picture. Just because you can follow each step doesn’t mean you can see the whole thing when it’s complete. Throughout the lesson I needed to explain a step by making related notes. I so became disorganized. I gave good explanations and was able to relate ideas but I was unable to model good notes.
This topic is neat because you see so many different ideas (i.e. summations, limits, factoring, simplifying, graphs, etc) and building this extremely elegant math concept which eventually because a simple operation (integration). If you can’t neatly show these concepts flow together on the chalkboard, then the lesson is not nearly as effective as it could be. I need to keep this in mind. It is an easy tangible improvement that can be made with practice and reflection.
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
Leadership In The Classroom
If I could form a hierarchy from my educational philosophy, at the top would be critical thinking, ethics and leadership. I believe that the teacher plays a vital role in fostering these ideas in the classroom. Through modeling the teacher is able to develop good habits that form the foundation to a student’s intellect. Leadership is a difficult concept to model because of its inherent social nature. Group dynamics, physical atmosphere and even the very activity have very complex effects of the development of leadership roles. How can you model good leadership? Well it is obvious that there are some fairly evident leadership aspects of teaching. Trust and communication play a huge role in the classroom as also they do in groups. The teacher is the leader of a class. He must develop his learning community where its members are all oriented to a common goal of content mastery. A good leader also has an intuitive sense about what his team needs to be successful. Teachers must acquire this skill in order to meet the individual ability levels and learning styles of the students. I still am not sure if this is effective in developing leader in the classroom but it’s a start. The following is an idea that is the start of something that, I think has potential.
To work, a group activity has to have structure and, in my opinion, some quirkiness. It has to be developed through routines and procedures. When the teacher declares that it is time for a group activity, the students need to know what the procedure is. It has to be memorable to be effective. The following group activity model was designed to create an opportunity for leaders in the class to develop while also providing a light peer structured atmosphere for the students.
The idea is to have this be the default group activity model. Students will be placed in groups. These groups will stay the same for a period of time. For each group activity, there would always be a new group of leaders. Each group would be given a letter for its name but the military phonetic alphabet would be used. For example, the A group would be called Alpha. The leader for that group would be called Alpha leader. I think this has the right amount of quirkiness that the students would find enjoyable and easy to remember.
Each time the leaders would be chosen based on some criteria known only to me. It might be the highest scores on a recent test or the lowest scores. It might be the most improved students. Whichever reason, the ideas is to give everyone the opportunity to hold the position while also allowing some students to hold it more. It is these students who will become the leaders of the class. I would like to hear feedback about this idea. I don't know how I feel yet about some students getting more opportunities to hold the position. I could see an argument being that someone may want it but I might not feel that they are not a leader. This might affect their self efficacy and have negative effects on their performance.
Somehow, I would want leaders to be evaluated whether it is extra credit or an actual grade. It doesn't have to be this way but I want to establish some incentive for not only being a leader but also being a good leader. This also needs to be worked out.
So what would the leaders do? Well, like any good leader, they would be focused on the success of their group. In this case, learning a particular concept or completing an assignment would define the primary goal of the group as well as the leader. These would also be the objectives which would be assessed. The leaders would also be responsible for ensuring that their entire group understand all concepts. If not then they would assist the student, assign someone in their group to assist the student or make sure the student gets the appropriate help. The leaders would be responsible for delivering any directions given to them by the teacher.
These are just some thoughts but hopefully I can bring this together into something more concrete. I believe this is a good start on developing a more student directed classroom rather than a teacher directed on.
First Lesson Preview
I am not doing anything special or new in my first lesson but my explanation might be unique. Like I mentioned before, effective teachers seem to be able to pull mathematics out of the vacuum in which it is placed. This doesn’t mean saying, “I can figure out how much to tip a waiter by using this simple algebraic equation.” To me, this is a huge misconception that dominates mathematics education. I interpret “real world application” as taking a complicated concept like a function and presenting it to them in a different way than the text might explain it (e.g. drawing on the board of a machine that takes raw materials as its inputs and outputs something useful). This gives the abstract a more concrete nature which is easier understood by minds that haven’t developed certain capacities of thinking.
Exponential growth falls under this category.
So what I am going to try is the paper folding problem?
I will use an actual sheet of paper for this lesson.
How thick is a sheet of paper? t inches
If I fold it in half how thick? 2t inches
In half again? 4t inches
Again? 8t inches
I will then have students approximate the measurement. It should be around 1/8 of an inch.
How thick would it be if you could fold the paper 20 times in half? 50 times?
They will most likely guess a few inches where the answer is the size of the Liberty One building for 20 times and to the sun for 50 times.
This is a common activity but the value is extremely unappreciated.
One instruction strategy that I am interested in is Socratic questioning. This strategy is used to expose underlying assumptions of the target. Once they are exposed you then undermine what they think they know by proving their assumptions false. If done effectively, the surprise that occurs is enough to engage them in the concepts.
The sequence is the following: t 2t 4t 8t 16t 32t …
Factor out a t: 1 2 4 8 16 32 …
Some famous mathematician once said that mathematics is about pattern recognition. What is the pattern? The thickness doubles every time.
We could also say that the thickness t is doubled every time the paper is folded in half.
t x 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 x ….
If the paper is folded 5 times how thick is it?
t – no folds
2t – 1 fold – 2t
2(2t) – 2 folds – 2^2t
2(2(2t)) – 3 folds – 2^3t
2(2(2(2t))) – 4 folds – 2^4t
2(2(2(2(2t)))) – 5 folds – 2^5t – 32t – 32 sheets of paper
This introductory activity is about engagement and relationship. Some students may be able to look at a graph of an exponential function and understand that it grows very quickly but this activity illustrates it by using tangible examples.